The short answer
Both keep your photos on hardware you own instead of a big-tech cloud. The difference is the shape: Immich is a server you run at home, with apps for your phone and web browser. Aegis Photo Voyager is a desktop app: install it, point it at your photos, and you are done. No containers, no database to maintain, no ports to open.
Side by side
| Immich | Aegis Photo Voyager | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Self-hosted photo server with web and mobile apps | Desktop app |
| Setup | Docker with Docker Compose; Linux recommended, Windows and macOS via Docker Desktop are discouraged | Install and open; Windows, macOS, Linux |
| Hardware | Server with at least 6 GB RAM (8 GB recommended) and 2+ CPU cores (4 recommended) | Your desktop or laptop; a graphics card speeds up AI but is optional |
| Phone backup | Yes, automatic and background backup from the iOS and Android apps | No; import from an iPhone or Android phone over USB, or from Google Takeout / iCloud exports |
| Users and sharing | Multiple users, partner sharing and public share links | One user on one computer; publish photo websites from collections |
| AI search | CLIP smart search, plus metadata, objects and faces | Local vision model writes a description of each photo; search by meaning; CLIP for similar photos |
| Faces and map | Face recognition and clustering; global map | Face recognition and clustering; map with GPS clustering |
| Photos on external drives | Files must be reachable by the server | Keeps working with drives unplugged, using local previews |
| Price and license | Free, open source (AGPL-3.0); optional paid supporter product key | Free for up to 2,000 photos. One-time license: Pro $47 (up to 100,000 photos) or Max $87 (no limit). No subscription. |
Which one fits you
Choose Immich if…
- you want every phone in the family to back up automatically
- several people need their own accounts and shared albums
- you want to browse your library from anywhere through a web browser
- you are comfortable running and updating a Docker server, and want free, open-source software
Choose Aegis Photo Voyager if…
- you want a private library without running a server
- your photos live on one computer and its external drives, some of them often unplugged
- you want AI that describes your photos, plus analytics, photo stories and photo websites
- you prefer a one-time price to supporting a server long term
Using both
They are not mutually exclusive. Some people let Immich handle phone backup and open the same photo folders in Photo Voyager on their desktop for curation and AI search. As long as your computer can read the folders where Immich stores the originals, Photo Voyager can import them.
Sources and how we compared
We make Aegis Photo Voyager, so we have an interest. Facts about other products come from their official websites and documentation, checked in November 2026. Products change; check their sites for current features and prices. If something here is out of date, please tell us and we will correct it.